Making Repository Public does not update the Default User Permissions
If I choose that Default User can see Public repositories, when one is created I can see it. Yet, if a make a repository private, then make it public again, the Default User can no longer see it.
If I want the Default User to see it again I need to go to the Permissions tab and activate it's permissions again.
NOTE: This is important when Anonymous Users are allowed, where they only see what the Default User sees.
#2 Updated by Ricardo Rodrigues 5 months ago
Thank for the reply. Thank you for clarifying, yet I still think that, if no one changed the Permissions settings, when I make a repository public it should place the Default User to its default permissions.
A simple use case is to ignore the Permissions tab and only use the Private Repository option. If I make it Public again, I expect the Default User to be able to see it again, which it doesn't. (This assumes that the Default User has at least viewing permission for Public Repos)
#3 Updated by Marcin Kuzminski [staff] 5 months ago
I see the problem that things get set up in a way that is hidden from the users.
What if we show additional message to the users with a quick link to permissions tab that would say they have to review default permissions after making a repo public ?
#4 Updated by Ricardo Rodrigues 5 months ago
I would actually move the Private Repo option to the Permissions. Or remove it! xD
It is an important option when creating a Repo, but I think it's best removed when you have access to the Permissions panel. Having the two actually does more harm than good in my opinion. Mainly because (from what I see) the Private Repo option just sets to 'None' the options of the Default User, or does it do anything else?